What happens when you poke, prod and pinch black widow spiders? You might be surprised…

31 January 2014 by Christopher Buddle, posted in Spiders

This is guest post, written by the great Arachnologist & Blogger, Catherine Scott. You can find her blogging over at spiderbytes.

widow 1

A stunning female western black widow (photo by S. McCann)

People seem to have a particular fear mixed with fascination when it comes to venomous animals, and whenever I talk about my work with black widows I am invariably asked questions like, “have you been bitten yet?” The answer is, of course, no. Spiders almost never bite people. I’m always quick to relate that in my experience black widows are not aggressive, even when I go around poking and prodding them with my bare hands.

Replicated experimental results always carry more weight than anecdotes, however, so I am delighted to share this recent paper: Poke but dont pinch: risk assessment and venom metering in the western black widow spider, Latrodectus hesperus.

Hey look!! An actual peer-reviewed research paper about the poking, prodding, and pinching of black widows, confirming that they are reluctant to bite, even when threatened. Not only that, but the study provides some cool data suggesting that these spiders are capable of assessing risks to make decisions about how to defend themselves.

Here are the details:

David Nelson and his coauthors wanted to know if black widows change their defensive behaviour depending on their level of threat. To find out, they used gelatin ‘fingers’ to place spiders in three different threatening situations: a ‘low threat’ attack was a single poke with one finger, a ‘medium threat’ was a series of prods simulating a more persistent attacker, and the ‘high threat’ was three a series of long pinches of the spider’s entire body between two fingers, as might be experienced if being grasped by a predator.

Fig. 1, from Nelson et al.

Fig. 1, from Nelson et al.

They found that the spiders engaged in several distinct defensive behaviours during these experimental attacks: retracting the legs toward the body, moving (often retreating), ‘silk-flicking’ (drawing sticky silk out of the spinnerets with last pair of legs and flinging it toward the attacking finger), ‘playing dead’ (curling up into a ball), and biting.

During low-threat, single pokes, no bites occurred. Most spiders were completely non-confrontational, simply moving away, and only rarely flicking silk.  When the threat level escalated to persistent prodding, the spiders changed their defensive behaviour: roughly half of them flicked silk, some played dead, and only one spider (out of 43) attempted to bite the offending finger. Silk-flicking is much safer than biting for a black widow – she can maintain her distance while flinging sticky silk to subdue or slow down her attacker. Biting, on the other hand, requires getting up close and personal with the assailant in order to pierce it with her tiny fangs, making her much more vulnerable to injury.

See the red tips of this black widow’s puny fangs? It’s a lot safer for her to keep her distance in threatening situations than get close enough to use them (Photo by S. McCann)

See the red tips of this black widow’s puny fangs? It’s a lot safer for her to keep her distance in threatening situations than get close enough to use them (Photo by S. McCann)

Only when the spiders were being pinched between two fingers (with the mouthparts already positioned right up against their ‘attackers’) did biting start to become a more common, last-resort tactic: 60% of the spiders bit the fingers as a result of being squeezed for an extended period of time, delivering on average 2.7 bites each. Pinching also resulted in silk-flicking by about half of the spiders, and a few played dead.

This is all great information, but when the spiders did bite the gelatin fingers, there was no way of knowing how much venom they injected, if any at all (sometimes venomous animals deliver ‘dry’ bites). The next question the researchers wanted to answer was, do the spiders control whether and how much venom they inject when biting? In particular, they wanted to know if the amount of venom injected would vary depending on the type of threat (in this case either pinching a leg with forceps, or grasping the abdomen with gloved fingers).

For this experiment they came up with a clever method to collect the venom: a small vial with a thin membrane over the opening was presented as a target for the spiders to bite. If a spider did bite, her fangs would pierce the membrane (the number of holes would indicate how many times) and any venom she expelled would be collected in the vial so the volume could subsequently be measured.

It turned out that more than half of all bites were dry (no venom was detected in the vials). The black widows delivered more bites per target when they were pinched on a leg than on the abdomen, but more venom was released with each bite when the abdomen was pinched. Being grasped by the body is a high-risk situation for a black widow because her abdomen is unarmored and vulnerable; a strong squeeze or puncture can be deadly. Pinching a single leg, on the other hand, represents a non-life threatening attack. Spiders can autotomize (drop) their limbs and survive without significant ill effects.

The team also found evidence that the spiders delivered more venom per bite when repeated threats were spaced 5 minutes apart than 5 seconds apart. Attacks after the longer intervals might have been interpreted as coming from new assailants, each requiring a larger dose of venom than a second or third bite to the same persistent attacker.

The results all indicate that black widows have fine control over how much venom they inject when biting. First, they can decide whether or not to use venom at all. Some spiders gave dry bites, then wet bites, as well as vice versa, demonstrating that dry bites were not simply a result of running out of venom. Furthermore, they can vary the amount of venom they inject during individual bites and in response to different kinds of threats.

Both silk and venom are metabolically expensive to manufacture, so it makes sense that spiders would be selective about when and how much of these resources to deploy in defense. This study suggests that they are able to assess risks and adjust their responses accordingly, only dipping into their reserves of silk and venom as the threat level escalates towards a life-or-death situation.

An unaggressive female black widow takes a stroll across my hand. Although I never grab spiders to pick them up, coaxing them onto my hands and letting them wander around on their own steam has never been a problem (Photo by S. McCann)

An unaggressive female black widow takes a stroll across my hand. Although I never grab spiders to pick them up, coaxing them onto my hands and letting them wander around on their own steam has never been a problem (Photo by S. McCann)

What does this all mean for humans? Grabbing and pinching spiders is generally not a good idea – they might get injured and could bite defensively. This is just good sense and didn’t require a scientific study to confirm, but the new data suggest that even if a black widow does bite, she’s not necessarily going to inject any venom. It’s also important to note that in the experiments where bites did occur, the spiders always had a ‘finger’ or target placed in direct contact with their mouthparts.

The most exciting thing this study tells us is that spiders can make decisions about how to respond to threats (which sometimes include humans) – further evidence of their incredible sophistication. Perhaps more importantly for the arachnophobic, it suggests that black widows would much rather conserve their valuable venom for use in dispatching their next meal than waste it on a human who is of no interest as prey!

Spiders in general are amazing creatures worthy of our admiration and respect. I hope that this new information about black widows might convince some that there is more about them to be fascinated by than to fear!


References and related reading:

Nelson et al. (2014). Poke but don't pinch: risk assessment and venom metering in the western black widow spider, Latrodectus hesperus Animal Behaviour DOI: 10.1016/j.anbehav.2013.12.019

Vetter, R. S. (1980). Defensive behavior of the black widow spider Latrodectus hesperus (Araneae: Theridiidae). Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology7(3), 187-193. doi:10.1007/BF00299363

W. Cranshaw (2014). Western widow fact sheet: http://www.ext.colostate.edu/pubs/insect/05605.html


23 Responses to “What happens when you poke, prod and pinch black widow spiders? You might be surprised…”

  1. rob Reply | Permalink

    I'm not a spider person... they instinctively repulse me. However, in support of your science log, I can verify that black widow spiders are not aggressive toward humans. At least not this human. When I was a kid, before I knew they were 'deadly', I used to scrape them and their webs away from our backyard water fountain pump bare-handed. Once, I woke up one morning with one against my thigh in bed. Guess it wanted to stay warm? In no case was I ever bitten. Or perhaps I was, but never got sick. Anyway, that's my black widow story.

  2. macromite Reply | Permalink

    Nice article and interesting paper. I think that is Whitney Cranshaw on the fact sheet, though, not 'Cronshaw'.

  3. Rick Reply | Permalink

    Excellent article. Reminds me of the year in college when I raised them. Saw flicking when prodded, but first response was usually to drop and curl up.

  4. Dustin C. Reply | Permalink

    I was a 11-year-old boy & got bit on the neck by one while sleeping, spending a month in the hospital. The risk is not only when you are being aggressive towards them, the aggressiveness may be unintentional but their perception & reaction is obviously the same. After that experience to this day I cannot help but completely freak-out with spiders, it's become a natural reaction (only thing I am afraid of, but the fear is earth-shattering to me)... Interesting and informative study though, but that was my life changing spider experience (by the way, it was a young Black Widow that bit me, not sure the difference, but they said a large amount of venom was injected into my skin at the time & I was lucky to survive). Not intending to be argumentative to your study and findings, just stating the reality on what can happen from a real experience.

  5. Johnny Reply | Permalink

    Great information, great article, great study! Also confirms my experiences (tons of black widows in my yard). I'm only disappointed that they didn't test with egg sacs, my experience also shows eggs make them very protective and seemingly aggressive.

  6. Michael Reply | Permalink

    Do you think it's possible for a black widow to bite after its dead? My son likes messing with spiders, and I have warned him of this type. When I came home from work today he had one in a glass of water dead. I have a fear of spiders, but I don't like killing anything. If they are venomous I'd rather not have them around

  7. greg Reply | Permalink

    if you live in the countryside sometimes drying clothes outside before hand them in needs a good shake....at least do not set them drying up on spider webs ... spiders concurred earth 250.000.000 to 500.000.000 years before and adopted easily mankind habits ...they cant see you and you cant see them all outside. Believe it or not being in the countryside means you are always close to a spider or many more.... great article for spiders ... for those hating spiders... i was stung by a wasp but i dont hate wasps or bees at least know what to do and how to react ...take precautions and read...its very menly-egoistic or menly-eccentric to hate everything if it harms us...what do we do from our point of view or we wish some speices or animals are gone or non existent for our "sake" and valueable time? Hating and the rest is the reason that brings fear and histerity, but things are much simpler if you move a little further may be a key factor for life in general

  8. CONNIE burr Reply | Permalink

    I am 44yrs old and I have recently been bitten by a northern black widow which I feel dry bit me--one weeks get while under my deck I received three bites to my right forearm by a southern black widow. After two trips to the ER and now on day six post bite my agony is somewhat bearable. If any one suffers a bite or two or three as I did at -108lb 5ft 2 KNOW THAT YOU ARE IN A SERIOUS MESS...the pain is unmanageable or unbearable....I literally believed twice I was NOT GOING TO MAKE IT! The venom ripped through my chest like a fire of great power the arm that I was bitten on still has vice like spasms but thank God they aren't constant I keep praying for my normal self again and I
    Suppose 10day post bite I can feel human again..... BE VERY CAREFUL OF THE BLACK WIDOW SHE IS

  9. Justin Kraemer Reply | Permalink

    I will kill these things whenever seen. Previously I have used acetone to hose them down before smashing them. This (the acetone) makes them curl up or "play dead" as some call it. First and foremost in my mind is the safety of my three very young children. Eradication is the best measure for any infestation no matter how small. Since the acetone smother and smash tactic I have upgraded my arsenal. I now have an aerosol spray that will kill them on contact or when they go about their freshly sprayed webs.

    Still, I love nature and appreciate them for what they are. I just don't want them around my family and I. The fact that they are everywhere at my workplace does not help either. Routinely, I am forced to defer maintenance operations during the night time until the sun is up and the spiders have retreated. I do not want to get bit!

  10. Cynthia Reply | Permalink

    Thank you for this article! I recently read an article about a young woman who opened a package of grapes. She said a black widow ran out of the package, ran up her arm, and attacked her. She was quite ill from the bite. I have been around a lot of black widows here in California, male and female, all life stages, and I have never seen one behave in such a manner as was described in the article. You've just confirmed my feeling that something is off about the story.

  11. Tami Schmidt Reply | Permalink

    Great article and I also enjoyed readers' comments and personal experiences. All good to know!

  12. Widower Reply | Permalink

    I kill every one I see. Got curious toddlers and it's not worth the risk.

  13. ARY Reply | Permalink

    I do kill them when they are around my toddlers' play area, but it is good to know they are not so likely to bite (although I do wonder how many in the experiment were guarding egg sacs; if none it would be a good follow-up). When they make webs in the toy trucks and such, they have to go. We did have a yard with quite a few and my then-one-year-old was the one who started finding them, and none of us got bitten. As far as I know, none of us pinched any of them!

  14. Ralph Reply | Permalink

    I try not to kill any spiders as they do a world of good against the insects here in Florida. I have spiders in my bedroom but try to let them alone . I do get bit but it isn't any worse than a mosquito bit.

  15. karen Reply | Permalink

    I love spiders....they look awesome smashed flat after I stomp on them ....☺

Leave a Reply

− three = 4