Pattern Recognition: Stick with the “Ugly Duckling” Rule?

5 November 2013 by Lowell Goldsmith - JID Jottings, posted in Uncategorized

Black-capped chicadee perched on a limb

Black-capped chickadee by Mdf, via a creative commons attribution share-alike license on Wikipedia

By Guest Blogger Abrar Qureshi, MD, MPH
Brigham and Women's Hospital, Boston, MA

White breasted nut hatch with patterned feathers

White breasted nut hatch by DickDaniels, via a creative commons attribution share-alike license on Wikipedia

In their recent study, Wazaefi at al asked dermatologists and non-dermatologists to cluster images of pigmented lesions from a series of patients and found that dermatologists did a better job at pattern recognition.  Boy, does that makes all dermatologists feel good!  We should be able to spot the difference between a black-capped chickadee and a white breasted nut-hatch in flight!  Maybe training our residents to recognize nature’s patterns outside the clinic will further embellish their clinical skills, with outings such as ‘astronomy night’ or ‘bird watching in the marshes’.

There are more layers to all this talk of ‘patterns’ – for example, are we looking too closely at pigmented lesions nowadays?  In the era of cross-polarization and spectroscopic gizmos, fortunately there are still some dermatologists who walk around clinic with a jeweler’s loupe in-hand.  Even more basic, there are other clinicians who use naked-eye inspections to examine their patients:  no loupes, forget fancy dermoscopes.  Is there a rationale to this variation among dermatologists when faced with a questionable pigmented lesion?  Are we looking for the ugly duckling through a scope?  Does the approach matter when seeing the whole patient versus looking at images of specific pigmented lesions?  Could the results of this study be different if dermatologists and non-dermatologists were asked to actually examine patients rather than work with images?



Wazaefi Y, Gaudy-Marqueste C, Avril M-F et al.  (2013) Evidence of a Limited Intra-Individual Diversity of Nevi: Intuitive Perception of Dominant Clusters Is a Crucial Step in the Analysis of Nevi by Dermatologists.  J Invest Dermatol doi:10.1038/jid.2013.183

Leave a Reply

× one = 8