Updated Range of Immensity for Arctotherium: New Record for Largest Known Bear

31 March 2011 by Anne-Marie Hodge, posted in Uncategorized

South America is currently home to a single species of ursid, the highly elusive and uniquely patterned spectacled bear ( Tremarctos ornatus ). This species is slightly diminutive in size compared to other bears, and is known for being fairly docile and highly vegetarian (one study found that the only 7% of spectacled bear scat sampled contained animal remains, and even those were just beetles and ants; Troya et al. 2004). These tractable traits, however, belie a fearsome family tree.spec_bear.jpg

The spectacled bear is actually the last surviving member of the group known as the short-faced bears—the tremarctines of the genera Arctodus and Arctotherium_. The most famous of these is Arctodus simuscontent&task=view&id=102&Itemid=60, known for having been found in great numbers in the La Brea Tar Pits. These bears were seriously formidable, attaining sizes that would have made modern grizzlies and polar bears look paltry.

During the Great American Biotic Interchange in the late Pliocene, ancestral tremarctines made their way across the newly minted isthmus that finally connected North and South America. Subsequent to this shuffle of species, many extinctions and radiations occurred, as species adapted to novel predators, prey, and habitats. Here is where we saw the tremarctines develop into the now infamous crew of car-sized carnivores, the last of which (excluding our spectacled bear) went extinct in the early Holocene (Soibelzon et al. 2005). The largest of the large in this group was Arctotherium angustidens, a South American behemoth of legendary proportions, currently known as the largest bear species ever to have lived.

Apparently A. angustidens could be even more immense than we were previously aware. A study recently published in the Journal of Paleontology (Soibelzon and Schubert 2011), describes the biggest bear fossil yet to be unearthed, an enormous individual—apparently a middle-aged male—discovered in Argentina.

Soibelzon and Schubert calculated that this individual had a mass ranging from anywhere between 983 and 2,042 kg (2,167-4,502 lb), depending on which formula is used to make the estimate. So, even using the most conservative formula, we had a bear that literally weighed a ton. For the sake of comparison, grizzlies ( Ursus arctos ) only tend to range up to 600 kg and polar bears ( Ursus maritimus ) up to 800 kg, although the record mass reported for a polar bear is ~1002 kg, on the low end of the estimates for this A. angustidens.

If bears used to attain such gargantuan sizes, and occasionally still do for some outlier individuals, why are the tremarctines now represented solely by the runty spectacled bears, which usually only range between 60 and 175 kg—an order of magnitude lower than some of their extinct relatives?

That phenomenon—the disappearance of the most massive species of a clade and persistence/radiation of smaller species—isn’t solely confined to Arctotherium. It appears that although the Pleistocene saw the development of massive ursids on several continents: Arctotherium in South America, Arctodus in North America, and the European Ursus spelaeus, none seemed to have made it out of the epoch alive. Arctotherium, however, did seem to burn out earlier than the other megabears, disappearing in the middle of the Pleistocene rather than making it through to the early Holocene like some of the other tremarctines.

Soibelzon and Schubert suggest that the large size of these species constrained their available dietary niche, and environmental conditions around the time of the Pleistocene-Holocene boundary favored smaller, more flexible species that were more general in their dietary habits and didn’t have quite the same enormous energy demand. Previous studies have supported the idea that increasing size sometimes brings on obligatory hypercarnivory, which is often the expressway to extinction. Van Valkenburgh et al. (2004), in a study of ancient North American carnivores, showed that at least two major clades exhibited an association between large body size, dietary specialization, and shorter species duration.

If large size is so hard to maintain, then why did it develop in the first place? The answer may have to do with the Great American Biotic Interchange, mentioned above. When the two American landmasses were connected, and animals were free to venture forth to new continents, they encountered ecological communities that were very different from what their adaptations had prepared them for back on their continent of origin. When the bears ambled south across the isthmus, they found a community full of large herbivores but with a very meager roster of carnivores with which to compete. At first, there were only two major predators in the area, A. angustidens and Smilodon, the infamous machairodont saber-tooth cat. A huge, widely available resource base loosened constraints on body size, and all of the open niche space allowed for diversification of the taxon.

Thus, the reign of A. angustidens was spectacular yet brief. As the process of adaptive radiation allowed carnivores to diversify, a more crowded scene began to emerge, resulting in more competition for resources. For example, Finarelli (2007) demonstrated that intraguild dynamics appear to be a factor in taxonomic diversification and the development hypercarnivory within three subfamilies of basal canids. In addition, environmental changes, such as the glacial cycles that punctuated the Pliestocene, could drastically change resource availability before carnivores had the time to adapt to new foraging conditions.

To offer an analogy, consider the difference in the practicality of driving an H3 hummer and a Prius. When oil is abundant and cheap, high demand for fuel can be accommodated. But when competition and/or scarcity, brought on by higher demand from the rest of your neighbors and possibly a change in environmental circumstances, the advantages of being more energy efficient and flexible will skyrocket. Likewise, the hugest of the huge bears stalked South America for a time during the Pleistocene, but did not make it to the home stretch of the epoch with its smaller and more generalist congeners.

The discovery of this extra-massive A. angustidens individual is important on multiple levels. It is extremely fascinating to have evidence demonstrating that bears once grew to proportions to which we were previously unaware. In addition, it brings up some interesting factors to consider when thinking about the effects of dietary specialization and intraguild competition in the face of declining resource availability.

Finarelli, J. 2007. Mechanisms behind active trends in body size evolution of the Canidae (Carnivora: Mammalia). American Naturalist 170: 876-885.
Soibelzon, L. H., E. P Tonni, and M. Bond. 2005. The fossil record of South American short-faced bears (Ursidae, Tremarctinae). Journal of South American Earth Sciences 20: 105-113.
Troya, V., F. Cuesta, and M. Paralvo. 2004. Food habits of Andean bears in the Oyachachi River Basin. Ursus 15: 57-60.
Van Valkenburgh, B., X. Wang, and J. Damuth. 2004. Cope’s rule, hypercarnivory, and extinction in North American canids. Science 306: 101-104.
Spectacled bear image credit
Arctotherium illustration: Soibelzon and Schubert (2011)

4 Responses to “Updated Range of Immensity for Arctotherium: New Record for Largest Known Bear”

  1. Laura Wheeler Reply | Permalink

     Hi Ann-Marie,

    I am sure we wouldn’t want an encounter with that huge bear!! It is interesting to hear the reasons as to why it became extinct. The theory:

    Previous studies have supported the idea that increasing size sometimes brings on obligatory hypercarnivory, which is often the expressway to extinction. 

    Does this apply to just animals?  The reason I ask is because of our rising obesity epidemic… :)

    Thanks for explaining why it disappeared. It makes sense that these bears were constrained by their available dietary niche, and environmental conditions.  Have you read Barbara Ferreira’s post about “The giant bunny of Minorca?” It is a huge rabbit which lived on the island 3 to 5 million years ago, and like the Arctodus simus, is extinct. The rabbit was roughly 10 times bigger than the common European rabbit.  Barbara tries to suggest reasons for its disappearance, although, unlike the Arctodus simus, it remains unknown.  

  2. Leopoldo Soibelzon Reply | Permalink

    Dear Anne-Marie, just congratulate you about your accurate and  well writen article!




  3. Mysun Sunsuion Reply | Permalink

    So big, don’t want to face it..

  4. 美国黑色星期五是哪天 Reply | Permalink

    {I have|I've} been {surfing|browsing} online
    more than {three|3|2|4} hours today, yet I never found any interesting article like yours.
    {It's|It is} pretty worth enough for me. {In my opinion|Personally|In my view}, if all {webmasters|site owners|website owners|web owners}
    and bloggers made good content as you did, the {internet|net|web} will be {much
    more|a lot more} useful than ever before.|
    I {couldn't|could not} {resist|refrain from} commenting.
    {Very well|Perfectly|Well|Exceptionally well}
    {I will|I'll} {right away|immediately} {take hold
    of|grab|clutch|grasp|seize|snatch} your {rss|rss feed} as
    I {can not|can't} {in finding|find|to find} your {email|e-mail} subscription {link|hyperlink} or {newsletter|e-newsletter} service.

    Do {you have|you've} any? {Please|Kindly} {allow|permit|let} me
    {realize|recognize|understand|recognise|know} {so that|in order that} I {may just|may|could}
    subscribe. Thanks.|
    {It is|It's} {appropriate|perfect|the best} time to make some plans for the future
    and {it is|it's} time to be happy. {I have|I've} read this post and if I could I {want to|wish to|desire
    to} suggest you {few|some} interesting things or {advice|suggestions|tips}.
    {Perhaps|Maybe} you {could|can} write next articles referring to this article.

    I {want to|wish to|desire to} read {more|even more} things about it!|
    {It is|It's} {appropriate|perfect|the best} time to make {a few|some} plans for {the future|the longer term|the long run} and {it is|it's} time to be happy.

    {I have|I've} {read|learn} this {post|submit|publish|put up} and if
    I {may just|may|could} I {want to|wish to|desire to} {suggest|recommend|counsel} you {few|some}
    {interesting|fascinating|attention-grabbing} {things|issues} or {advice|suggestions|tips}.
    {Perhaps|Maybe} you {could|can} write {next|subsequent} articles {relating to|referring
    to|regarding} this article. I {want to|wish to|desire to} {read|learn} {more|even more} {things|issues} {approximately|about}
    {I have|I've} been {surfing|browsing} {online|on-line}
    {more than|greater than} {three|3} hours {these days|nowadays|today|lately|as of late}, {yet|but} I {never|by no means} {found|discovered}
    any {interesting|fascinating|attention-grabbing} article like yours.
    {It's|It is} {lovely|pretty|beautiful} {worth|value|price} {enough|sufficient} for me.

    {In my opinion|Personally|In my view}, if all {webmasters|site owners|website owners|web owners} and bloggers made
    {just right|good|excellent} {content|content material}
    as {you did|you probably did}, the {internet|net|web} {will be|shall be|might be|will probably be|can be|will likely be}
    {much more|a lot more} {useful|helpful} than ever before.|
    Ahaa, its {nice|pleasant|good|fastidious} {discussion|conversation|dialogue} {regarding|concerning|about|on the topic of} this {article|post|piece of writing|paragraph} {here|at
    this place} at this {blog|weblog|webpage|website|web site}, I have read all that, so {now|at this time} me also commenting
    {here|at this place}.|
    I am sure this {article|post|piece of writing|paragraph} has
    touched all the internet {users|people|viewers|visitors}, its really
    really {nice|pleasant|good|fastidious} {article|post|piece of writing|paragraph} on building up new {blog|weblog|webpage|website|web site}.|
    Wow, this {article|post|piece of writing|paragraph} is {nice|pleasant|good|fastidious}, my {sister|younger sister} is
    analyzing {such|these|these kinds of} things, {so|thus|therefore} I am going to {tell|inform|let know|convey} her.|
    {Saved as a favorite|bookmarked!!}, {I really like|I like|I love} {your blog|your site|your web site|your website}!|
    Way cool! Some {very|extremely} valid points! I appreciate you
    {writing this|penning this} {article|post|write-up} {and the|and also the|plus the} rest of the {site
    is|website is} {also very|extremely|very|also really|really} good.|
    Hi, {I do believe|I do think} {this is an excellent|this is a great} {blog|website|web site|site}.
    I stumbledupon it ;) {I will|I am going to|I'm
    going to|I may} {come back|return|revisit} {once again|yet again} {since I|since i have} {bookmarked|book marked|book-marked|saved as a favorite}
    it. Money and freedom {is the best|is the greatest} way to
    change, may you be rich and continue to {help|guide} {other people|others}.|
    Woah! I'm really {loving|enjoying|digging} the template/theme of
    this {site|website|blog}. It's simple, yet effective.

    A lot of times it's {very hard|very difficult|challenging|tough|difficult|hard} to get that
    "perfect balance" between {superb usability|user friendliness|usability}
    and {visual appearance|visual appeal|appearance}.

    I must say {that you've|you have|you've} done a {awesome|amazing|very good|superb|fantastic|excellent|great} job
    with this. {In addition|Additionally|Also}, the blog loads {very|extremely|super} {fast|quick} for me on {Safari|Internet explorer|Chrome|Opera|Firefox}.
    {Superb|Exceptional|Outstanding|Excellent} Blog!|
    These are {really|actually|in fact|truly|genuinely} {great|enormous|impressive|wonderful|fantastic} ideas in {regarding|concerning|about|on the topic of} blogging.

    You have touched some {nice|pleasant|good|fastidious} {points|factors|things} here.
    Any way keep up wrinting.|
    {I love|I really like|I enjoy|I like|Everyone loves} what you guys
    {are|are usually|tend to be} up too. {This sort of|This type
    of|Such|This kind of} clever work and {exposure|coverage|reporting}!
    Keep up the {superb|terrific|very good|great|good|awesome|fantastic|excellent|amazing|wonderful} works guys I've {incorporated||added|included} you guys to {|my|our||my personal|my own} blogroll.|
    {Howdy|Hi there|Hey there|Hi|Hello|Hey}! Someone in my {Myspace|Facebook} group shared this {site|website} with us so
    I came to {give it a look|look it over|take a look|check it out}.
    I'm definitely {enjoying|loving} the information. I'm {book-marking|bookmarking} and will
    be tweeting this to my followers! {Terrific|Wonderful|Great|Fantastic|Outstanding|Exceptional|Superb|Excellent} blog and {wonderful|terrific|brilliant|amazing|great|excellent|fantastic|outstanding|superb} {style and
    design|design and style|design}.|
    {I love|I really like|I enjoy|I like|Everyone loves} what you guys {are|are usually|tend to be} up too.
    {This sort of|This type of|Such|This kind of} clever work and {exposure|coverage|reporting}!
    Keep up the {superb|terrific|very good|great|good|awesome|fantastic|excellent|amazing|wonderful} works guys I've
    {incorporated|added|included} you guys to {|my|our|my personal|my own} blogroll.|
    {Howdy|Hi there|Hey there|Hi|Hello|Hey} would
    you mind {stating|sharing} which blog platform you're {working
    with|using}? I'm {looking|planning|going} to start my own blog
    {in the near future|soon} but I'm having a {tough|difficult|hard} time {making
    a decision|selecting|choosing|deciding} between BlogEngine/Wordpress/B2evolution and Drupal.

    The reason I ask is because your {design and style|design|layout} seems different
    then most blogs and I'm looking for something {completely unique|unique}.
    P.S {My apologies|Apologies|Sorry} for {getting|being} off-topic but I had
    to ask!|
    {Howdy|Hi there|Hi|Hey there|Hello|Hey} would you mind letting me
    know which {webhost|hosting company|web host} you're {utilizing|working with|using}?
    I've loaded your blog in 3 {completely different|different} {internet browsers|web
    browsers|browsers} and I must say this blog loads a lot
    {quicker|faster} then most. Can you {suggest|recommend} a good {internet hosting|web hosting|hosting}
    provider at a {honest|reasonable|fair} price? {Thanks
    a lot|Kudos|Cheers|Thank you|Many thanks|Thanks}, I appreciate
    {I love|I really like|I like|Everyone loves} it {when people|when individuals|when folks|whenever people} {come together|get together}
    and share {opinions|thoughts|views|ideas}. Great {blog|website|site}, {keep it up|continue the good work|stick with it}!|
    Thank you for the {auspicious|good} writeup. It in fact was a amusement account it.
    Look advanced to {far|more} added agreeable from you!

    {By the way|However}, how {can|could} we communicate?|
    {Howdy|Hi there|Hey there|Hello|Hey} just wanted to give you a quick heads up.

    The {text|words} in your {content|post|article} seem to be running off the screen in {Ie|Internet explorer|Chrome|Firefox|Safari|Opera}.
    I'm not sure if this is a {format|formatting} issue
    or something to do with {web browser|internet browser|browser}
    compatibility but I {thought|figured} I'd post to let you know.
    The {style and design|design and style|layout|design} look great though!

    Hope you get the {problem|issue} {solved|resolved|fixed}
    soon. {Kudos|Cheers|Many thanks|Thanks}|
    This is a topic {that is|that's|which is} {close to|near to} my heart...
    {Cheers|Many thanks|Best wishes|Take care|Thank you}!
    {Where|Exactly where} are your contact details though?|
    It's very {easy|simple|trouble-free|straightforward|effortless} to find out
    any {topic|matter} on {net|web} as compared to
    {books|textbooks}, as I found this {article|post|piece
    of writing|paragraph} at this {website|web site|site|web page}.|
    Does your {site|website|blog} have a contact page? I'm having {a
    tough time|problems|trouble} locating it but, I'd like to {send|shoot} you an {e-mail|email}.

    I've got some {creative ideas|recommendations|suggestions|ideas}
    for your blog you might be interested in hearing. Either way, great {site|website|blog} and I look forward to seeing it {develop|improve|expand|grow}
    over time.|
    {Hola|Hey there|Hi|Hello|Greetings}! I've been {following|reading} your {site|web site|website|weblog|blog} for {a long time|a while|some time} now
    and finally got the {bravery|courage} to go ahead and
    give you a shout out from {New Caney|Kingwood|Huffman|Porter|Houston|Dallas|Austin|Lubbock|Humble|Atascocita} {Tx|Texas}!
    Just wanted to {tell you|mention|say} keep up the {fantastic|excellent|great|good} {job|work}!|
    Greetings from {Idaho|Carolina|Ohio|Colorado|Florida|Los angeles|California}!
    I'm {bored to tears|bored to death|bored} at work so I decided to {check
    out|browse} your {site|website|blog} on my iphone during lunch break.

    I {enjoy|really like|love} the {knowledge|info|information} you {present|provide} here and can't
    wait to take a look when I get home. I'm {shocked|amazed|surprised} at how {quick|fast} your blog loaded
    on my {mobile|cell phone|phone} .. I'm not even using WIFI,
    just 3G .. {Anyhow|Anyways}, {awesome|amazing|very good|superb|good|wonderful|fantastic|excellent|great} {site|blog}!|
    Its {like you|such as you} {read|learn} my {mind|thoughts}!
    You {seem|appear} {to understand|to know|to grasp} {so much|a
    lot} {approximately|about} this, {like you|such
    as you} wrote the {book|e-book|guide|ebook|e book} in it or something.
    {I think|I feel|I believe} {that you|that you simply|that you just} {could|can}
    do with {some|a few} {%|p.c.|percent} to {force|pressure|drive|power} the message {house|home} {a bit|a little bit}, {however|but} {other than|instead of}
    that, {this is|that is} {great|wonderful|fantastic|magnificent|excellent} blog.
    {A great|An excellent|A fantastic} read. {I'll|I will} {definitely|certainly} be back.|
    I visited {multiple|many|several|various} {websites|sites|web sites|web pages|blogs}
    {but|except|however} the audio {quality|feature} for audio songs {current|present|existing} at this {website|web site|site|web
    page} is {really|actually|in fact|truly|genuinely} {marvelous|wonderful|excellent|fabulous|superb}.|
    {Howdy|Hi there|Hi|Hello}, i read your blog {occasionally|from time
    to time} and i own a similar one and i was just {wondering|curious} if you get a lot of spam {comments|responses|feedback|remarks}?
    If so how do you {prevent|reduce|stop|protect against} it, any plugin or anything you can {advise|suggest|recommend}?
    I get so much lately it's driving me {mad|insane|crazy} so
    any {assistance|help|support} is very much appreciated.|
    Greetings! {Very helpful|Very useful} advice {within this|in this particular} {article|post}!
    {It is the|It's the} little changes {that make|which will make|that produce|that will make} {the biggest|the largest|the greatest|the most
    important|the most significant} changes. {Thanks a lot|Thanks|Many thanks} for sharing!|
    {I really|I truly|I seriously|I absolutely} love {your blog|your site|your website}..
    {Very nice|Excellent|Pleasant|Great} colors & theme.
    Did you {create|develop|make|build} {this website|this site|this web site|this amazing site} yourself?
    Please reply back as I'm {looking to|trying to|planning to|wanting to|hoping to|attempting to} create {my own|my very own|my own personal} {blog|website|site} and {would like to|want
    to|would love to} {know|learn|find out} where you got this from or {what
    the|exactly what the|just what the} theme {is
    called|is named}. {Thanks|Many thanks|Thank you|Cheers|Appreciate it|Kudos}!|
    {Hi there|Hello there|Howdy}! This {post|article|blog post} {couldn't|could not}
    be written {any better|much better}! {Reading through|Looking at|Going through|Looking through} this {post|article} reminds me of my previous roommate!
    He {always|constantly|continually} kept {talking
    about|preaching about} this. {I will|I'll|I am going to|I most certainly will} {forward|send}
    {this article|this information|this post} to him.
    {Pretty sure|Fairly certain} {he will|he'll|he's going to} {have a good|have a very good|have a great} read.
    {Thank you for|Thanks for|Many thanks for|I appreciate you for} sharing!|
    {Wow|Whoa|Incredible|Amazing}! This blog looks {exactly|just} like my old one!
    It's on a {completely|entirely|totally} different {topic|subject} but it has pretty much the
    same {layout|page layout} and design. {Excellent|Wonderful|Great|Outstanding|Superb} choice of colors!|
    {There is|There's} {definately|certainly} {a lot to|a great deal to} {know about|learn about|find out about} this {subject|topic|issue}.
    {I like|I love|I really like} {all the|all of the} points {you made|you've made|you
    have made}.|
    {You made|You've made|You have made} some {decent|good|really good}
    points there. I {looked|checked} {on the internet|on the web|on the
    net} {for more info|for more information|to find out more|to learn more|for additional information} about the issue and found {most individuals|most people} will go along with your views on {this website|this site|this web site}.|
    {Hi|Hello|Hi there|What's up}, I {log on to|check|read} your {new stuff|blogs|blog} {regularly|like every week|daily|on a regular basis}.
    Your {story-telling|writing|humoristic} style is {awesome|witty}, keep
    {doing what you're doing|up the good work|it up}!|
    I {simply|just} {could not|couldn't} {leave|depart|go
    away} your {site|web site|website} {prior to|before} suggesting that I {really|extremely|actually} {enjoyed|loved} {the
    standard|the usual} {information|info} {a person|an individual} {supply|provide} {for your|on your|in your|to your}
    {visitors|guests}? Is {going to|gonna} be {back|again}
    {frequently|regularly|incessantly|steadily|ceaselessly|often|continuously} {in order to|to} {check up on|check out|inspect|investigate cross-check} new posts|
    {I wanted|I needed|I want to|I need to} to thank you for this {great|excellent|fantastic|wonderful|good|very good} read!!
    I {definitely|certainly|absolutely} {enjoyed|loved} every {little bit of|bit
    of} it. {I have|I've got|I have got} you {bookmarked|book
    marked|book-marked|saved as a favorite} {to check out|to look at} new
    {stuff you|things you} post厊

Leave a Reply

+ two = 3